Dylan Voller Wins Landmark Social Media Defamation Case

Media Release – 24/06/2019

Former youth detainee Dylan Voller, launched defamation action against three media organisations over comments made by public users on the respective Facebook pages of those organisations.

Today in the Supreme Court of NSW, Justice Rothman found in essence that each of the defendants were not merely conduits for the comments. They provided a forum for the publication of comments (the Facebook pages) and encouraged, for their own commercial purposes, the publication of comments.

Moreover, the Judge found that each defendant was aware that comments on its initial posting were likely and more probably than not going to include defamatory material. Further, it was within their capability to hide the comments, monitor them and “un-hide” acceptable ones.

In those circumstances Justice Rothman found that the defendants were liable as publishers of the comments.

The media outlet Facebook pages included: The Sydney Morning Herald, The Australian, the Centralian Advocate, Sky News Australia and The Bolt Report.

Principal Solicitor Peter O’Brien of O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors, said “this is a significant win for Dylan Voller, and others who may find themselves an object of public scrutiny, as this kind of free for all commentary can be extremely negative, untruthful and damaging to a person’s mental health”.

“We are very happy with the judgement as it clarifies the law around social media platforms and paves the way for a broader understanding of how defamation proceedings can protect people in the context of new technology. It also encourages a more responsible and socially minded approach by the large media companies to their use of Facebook”.

The Judge also ordered that the defendants were to pay Mr. Voller’s legal costs.