This week, the University of Wollongong inquiry reached the witness at the centre of it, and Peter O’Brien is on the record acting for Alyssa White.
ABC reported a full article on the case, read it below.
In the Media
Welcome to our page dedicated to showcasing the publications and recognition received by our talented lawyers. Our legal team has high regard within the industry and received numerous accolades for their expertise and contributions to the field of law.
2026
O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors solicitor Stewart O’Connell has been quoted in The Guardian following a Federal Court ruling in the Cairo Takeaway defamation matter.
The Federal Court found that pro-Israel activist Ofir Birenbaum breached the confidential settlement he had reached with Cairo Takeaway, after publicly claiming the outcome was a “complete vindication.” In this case, the court ruled those claims were highly misleading and inconsistent with the terms of what had been agreed between the parties.
In the article, The Guardian reported on the ruling and sought comment from Stewart O’Connell, who represented Cairo Takeaway throughout the proceedings.
“It was unfortunate that all the hard work that went into achieving a compromise in this matter was undone by people who wanted to spin that compromise into some kind of victory.”
— Stewart O’Connell, O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors
The case is a significant example of how confidential settlement agreements are legally enforceable, and how parties who publicly misrepresent their terms can face further court action as a result.
O’Brien Solicitors Featured in Sydney Morning Herald: Hannah Thomas Civil Case Against NSW Police
Our firm is representing Hannah Thomas, the former Greens candidate who suffered permanent eyesight damage after being arrested at an anti-Israel protest in Sydney in 2025.
The Sydney Morning Herald reported exclusively on 10 June 2026 that NSW Police have admitted to battery, false imprisonment and causing “harm and damage” to Ms Thomas, and have conceded she is entitled to damages in her civil case before the NSW Supreme Court. The case also involves allegations of misfeasance in public office and malicious prosecution.
Peter O’Brien On ABC Four Corners: Police Misconduct
Peter O’Brien appeared on ABC Four Corners, Australia’s leading investigative journalism program, speaking on the systemic failures in NSW police accountability and the urgent need for reform.
Peter is currently representing Samantha Testalamuta, who was allegedly assaulted by NSW Police officers responding to a noise complaint at her home. Her case is one of hundreds our firm has pursued against police for alleged misconduct and excessive force.
Watch the full Four Corners episode Brutal Force now via the link below.
Peter O’Brien in SBS NITV
Our Principal Solicitor, Peter O’Brien, was mentioned in an article by the NITV about Ms Dempsey’s case. The article included the following quote.
“Ms. Dempsey deserved humane and proper care”
“The failure of the NT police to ensure this has resulted in a preventable death that has devastated her family and left her five children to grow up without a mother.”
Peter O’Brien mentioned in the National Indigenous Times on representing family of Kumanjayi Dempsey who died in custody
Our Principal Solicitor, Peter O’Brien was mentioned in the National Indigenous Times about representing the family of Kumanjayi Dempsey, who died in custody.
Peter O’Brien said:
“Ms Dempsey deserved humane and proper care.” And:
“The failure of the NT police to ensure this has resulted in a preventable death that has devastated her family and left her five children to grow up without a mother.”
“The police have a duty to protect citizens in their care and not neglect them to the extent they did with Ms Dempsey,” Mr O’Brien said.
Sydney Criminal Solicitor Wilson Tighe Mentioned in Sydney Morning Herald Article
Wilson Tighe, our top criminal solicitor, was mentioned in a Sydney Morning Herald article after he defended an 18-year-old protester who was arrested at the Sydney protests in February 2026. The young man was arrested in Surry Hills.
Peter O’Brien Mentioned in ABC Article
Our Principal Solicitor, Peter O’Brien, represented Ben Batterham, who received a payout from NSW government for wrongful prosecution. From the article by ABC:
“For Ben Batterham, it has been a long and torturous process to have been charged, then to have been acquitted,” he said.
“To have now settled a suit against the state in relation to the manner in which he was prosecuted, that’s been a long and arduous process for him, and hopefully now he can move on with his life.”
Mr O’Brien said lessons could be learned from the case.
“It’s a very good example of why prosecution authorities need to exercise the discretion to not proceed and to not bill proceedings that are inevitably doomed, as this one was.”
2025
Peter O’Brien Quoted in ABC Article: O’Brien is representing the Balzan family in a civil claim.
Our Principal Solicitor, Peter O’Brien, is representing Adam Balzan, the father of Brad who was shot by a NSW police officer, in a civil claim against the state. The ABC article stated that a coroner has concluded that police went too far in the level of force they used when they fatally shot Sydney man Bradley Balzan. Balzan was killed by an officer in 2020 while in the backyard of his Western Sydney home.
Their lawyer Peter O’Brien said Mr Balzan’s father Adam Balzan had lodged a civil claim against the state of NSW, arguing his son should never have been stopped.
“The family will be looking very carefully at these findings,” Mr O’Brien said.
“I can only begin to imagine how grief struck they are. This young man was a beautiful young boy who had extensive love for his family.“Their grief will continue and be immeasurable.”
Read the full article below.
Readf more on the case: https://obriensolicitors.com.au/death-of-bradley-balzan-media-release/
News.com Shared Quote by Peter O’Brien
The article: Police officer who allegedly assaulted Greens candidate Hannah Thomas faces fresh charge
News.com quoted our Principal Solicitor, Peter O’Brien:
“The additional offence of inflicting grievous bodily harm reflected the severity of the injury sustained by their client, and reinforced the troubling nature of the way in which police are dealing with people during public assemblies.
“Police (are there) to preserve law and order in a peaceful democracy, and protesters whose dissent is vital to democracy,” he said.
Peter O’Brien in ABC Article
The article quoted our Principal Solicitor, Peter O’Brien, on Hannah Thomas’ case:
“The addition of an offence of inflicting grievous bodily harm reflects the severity of the injury sustained by our client,” Mr O’Brien said in a statement on Wednesday.
“[This] reinforces the troubling nature of the way in which police are dealing with people during public assemblies where both are; in fact and law aligned — police to preserve law and order in a peaceful democracy, and protesters whose dissent is vital to democracy,” he said.
Peter O’Brien Quoted in The Guardian
Article: NSW police officer who allegedly assaulted former Greens candidate Hannah Thomas charged with grievous bodily harm
“O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors announced earlier this month that their client would be claiming damages for malicious prosecution, assault and battery by police officers and misfeasance in public office.
“We are seeking redress not only for Ms Thomas’s individual suffering, including the ongoing injury to her right eye, but also to uphold the broader principle that police powers must never be abused,” Thomas’ solicitor, Peter O’Brien, said at the time.”
Our Principal Solicitor, Peter O’Brien, in News.com.au
Solicitor Peter O’Brien, who formed part of the large legal team representing Mr Lees, said the landmark decision was a “win for democracy” that would protect the right to political communication in Australia.
“I can say on behalf of all people who respect and understand it’s a fundamental part of our existence in Australian democracy that this is a win for democracy and it’s a win for the ability to dissent by way of public assembly and protest,” Mr O’Brien said in a statement on Thursday afternoon.
“It settles clearly that the government cannot insert arbitrary, ill thought out amendments into legislation which might water down the very foundational bedrock of what a community and what a democracy is all about.
“And that is understanding and appreciating the right to protest, and that is what this government has failed to do in this instance.”
Our Special Counsel, Stewart O’Connell, Quoted in The Sydney Morning Herald on Belmore protesters
In court on Friday, Stewart O’Connell, our Special Counsel, acted for some of the Belmore protesters. In a Sydney Morning Herald article, O’Connell indicated that the police had been told to act “contrary to the law” when they arrested the protesters.
“It appears to be a direction coming from the top, a systematic issue”
– Stewart O’Connell.
The article also stated:
‘O’Connell said it was “extremely concerning” that a senior officer appeared to have a “fundamental” misunderstanding of the law.’
9 News Australia: Police officer charged with assault over arrest of Hannah Thomas at protest
9News held an interview with our Principal Solicitor, Peter O’Brien, to discuss the latest developments on Hannah Thomas case.
BBC: Police Officer Charged With Assault at Pro-Palestinian Protest in Sydney – September 2025
Peter O’Brien was quoted in this BBC article:
Outside the court, her lawyer Peter O’Brien said the long-term impact on Thomas’s right eye was still unknown, according to the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC).
Mr O’Brien said he would be filing civil proceedings against police in the NSW Supreme Court over the incident, including for malicious prosecution, assault and battery by police, malfeasance in public office and collateral abuse of process.
The Australian: Cop’s employment ‘under review’ after allegedly assaulting Hannah Thomas – September 2025
Peter O’Brien spoke outside court to multiple press after defending Hannah Thomas where all criminal charges were dropped.
ABC News: All Charges Dropped Against Hannah Thomas
Speaking after court, Peter O’Brien said: “The civil proceedings foreshadowed by Mr O’Brien, which he said are to be filed in the Supreme Court today, will include malicious prosecution and assault and battery by police.”
Sydney Morning Herald : Hannah Thomas to Launch Civil Case Against NSW Police
Outside Bankstown Local Court, Peter O’Brien confirmed civil proceedings: “It’s a very serious injury, and compensation will be sought.”
The Guardian: NSW Police Drop Charges Against Hannah Thomas
Peter O’Brien told reporters from The Guardian: “The charges [against Thomas] were clearly unsustainable from the very beginning, and as a result, they’ve now been … withdrawn. And that should have happened probably a long time ago.”
Peter O’Brien Speaks to The Guardian After Police Persist with Charges – Jul 15, 2025
In July 2025, The Guardian reported that the NSW police are yet to withdraw protest charge against Hannah Thomas as promised as she pleads not guilty.
“On Monday, in a statement calling for charges against Thomas to be withdrawn, her lawyers at O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors alleged that a police officer punched her in the face during the protest, resulting in “extensive and serious injury to her eye.”
– Jordyn Beazley, The Guardian.
Stewart O’Connell Speaks to News.com on Police’s Actions Following Hannah Thomas’ Assault – Jul 15, 2025
“The lawyer representing a former Greens candidate, who he says was “punched” by police during an anti-Israel protest in Sydney, has slammed officers for declining “an opportunity to show some accountability”.
– Nathan Schmidt, News.com
Peter O’Brien gave an exclusive to The Sydney Morning Herald – Jul 14, 2025
“Hannah Thomas’s lawyer, Peter O’Brien, to take the unusual step of demanding the charges against her be dropped, while also confirming that she will launch a civil case, saying she had been “the victim of gratuitous police brutality and excessive use of force”.
– Michael McGowan and Kate McClymont in the Sydney Morning Herald
Peter O’Brien to The Guardian After Watching Body-Cam Footage of Police Assault – Jul 14, 2025
“‘Hannah Thomas was punched in the face by a police officer, her lawyers claim.’
Peter O’Brien gave an interview to The Guardian, stating that Former Greens candidate will sue the state of NSW alleging excessive use of force, solicitor says.
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors in The Guardian – Jun 30, 2025
Our firm was recognised in The Guardian for our work defending civil liberties and holding authorities accountable.
Following the recent protest in Sydney, we are representing several individuals, including Hannah Thomas, who suffered significant injuries during her interaction with police.
Peter O’Brien Press Conference on Josh Lees – Palestine Action Group – Jun 20, 2025
Our client Josh Lees, representing the Palestine Action Group (PAG), stood on the steps of the NSW Supreme Court to launch a constitutional challenge against the controversial protest laws passed earlier this year by the Minns Labor Government. Peter was there to answer questions from the press.
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors in The Australian and News.com – Jun 19, 2025
A number of media outlets published about our client’s case, Josh Lees for the Palestine Action Group:
“A member of the team representing Mr Lees, Peter O’Brien, from O’Briens Solicitors, claimed outside court that the laws were not about protecting parishioners, and the legislation didn’t comment on harassing, menacing or intimidating parishioners.”
“One of a large legal team representing Mr Lees, Peter O’Brien, from O’Briens Solicitors, claimed outside court that the laws were not about protecting parishioners, and the legislation didn’t comment on harassing, menacing or intimidating parishioners.”
– Clareese Packer.
Peter O’Brien UTS Graduation Speech – May 12, 2025
On 12 May 2025, Peter O’Brien, a celebrated advocate for civil liberties and a fearless voice in Australian law, stood before the graduating class of UTS Law to deliver a speech unlike any other. Rather than delve into global legal trends or lofty platitudes, Peter O’Brien chose to reflect on his own tumultuous and triumphant journey through the legal profession.
2023-2024
Sidnie Sarang on ABC’s Betrayal: The Hannah Grundy Case – Oct 14, 2024
In a thrilling episode of ABC’s Betrayal, our very own top criminal lawyer, Sidnie Sarang, took the spotlight!
In the viral episode, Sarang shared the shocking story behind the high-profile case of her client, Hannah Grundy.
Catch the episode in the link below if you haven’t already seen it.
Sky News, The Australian and Daily Telegraph Apologies to our Client, an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Dance Group – Jun 8, 2024
Sky News, The Australian and the Daily Telegraph apologised to our clients, an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Dance Group and its members for using their photograph in an unrelated news report.
The three news groups also apologised for the manner in which they published the photo, which caused significant hurt and distress. Our Senior Associate, Stewart O’Connell, received a successful settlement in the media defamation case for our clients.
Peter O’Brien’s Insightful Appearance on SBS Insight’s “Trial By Media” – Jun 7, 2024
Peter O’Brien made a compelling appearance on SBS’s renowned program, “Insight.”
The episode, ‘Trial By Media‘, part of the show’s 2024 season (Episode 14), tackled pressing legal issues that resonate deeply with the Australian community.
Peter O’Brien in ABC News ´Background Briefing´ Podcast – Mar 21, 2024
Peter O’Brien, our Principal Solicitor, was quoted by ABC podcast BACKGROUND BRIEFING in their latest episode: Stop and Search | The Botched Backyard Operation. In the episode, they go into detail about what happened in Brad´s tragic last few moments after police officer fatally shot the young man as part of their proactive policing strategy that went horribly wrong. Peter is representing Brad´s father, Adam Balzan.
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors are experts in suing the police.
Listen to the podcast episode from the link below.
Interview with Professor Simon Rice: Sydney Law Professor Sues NSW Police – Dec 12, 2023
Brian Massone, our Civil Solicitor, interviewed our recent client, Law Professor Simon Rice, who we helped sue the NSW Police. Rice was on the sidelines of a student protest when police arrested him unlawfully.
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors are experts in suing police for unlawful arrests.
Law Society Journal interviews Peter O’Brien on the topic of police powers to search, detain and arrest – Oct 18, 2023
Peter O’Brien, our Principal Solicitor, spoke to LSJ on whether the police’s power to search, detain, and arrest needs overhauling.
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors are experts in suing police for unlawful searches.
ABC interviews Peter O’Brien as the Police search season, also known as musical festival season, starts – Sep 30, 2023
Our principal solicitor, Peter O’Brien discussed the issue of juveniles going into Queensland watch houses with The Guardian.
Our firm is expert in suing police for unlawful searches.
Guardian interviews Peter O’Brien on the Queensland watch house issue – Aug 31, 2023
Our principal solicitor, Peter O’Brien discussed the issue of police searches with the ABC.
Running a Successful Claim for Malicious Prosecution with Tahn O’Rourke and Peter O’Brien – Aug 24, 2023
William Spedding was awarded $1.8 million in damages in a claim against the State of NSW for malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office and abuse of process after he was arrested and charged during investigations into the disappearance of William Tyrell. William Spedding’s counsel Tahn O’Rourke, Sir Owen Dixon Chambers, and principal solicitor, Peter O’Brien, O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors, discuss the case they ran, and the judgments in the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal, in the first of three insightful presentations.
Subscribers can watch the full video at: https://lnkd.in/eKtrNk5V
Peter O’Brien comments on the failed appeal by the State of NSW on the Bill Spedding decision – Aug 9, 2023
On August 9, our Principal solicitor Peter O’Brien, commented to the ABC about the State of NSW losing its appeal against the decision in favor of Bill Spedding in his claim against the NSW Police Force.
On Channel 9, Peter described the State’s decision to appeal as “an act of lunacy”.
See the Channel 7 Story here. See the Channel 9 story here (and also in the video below)
Peter O’Brien comments on the Lehrmann prosecution mishandling – Aug 4, 2023
On August 2, our Principal solicitor Peter O’Brien, commented to Channel 7 about Bruce Lehrmann threatening to demand millions if the A.C.T. Prosecutor mishandled rape allegations in relation to Brittany Higgins. He also commented in a subsequent item on the same topic on August 4.
Bail Applications with Wilson Tighe and Tim Rayner – Jul 11, 2023
Recently our lawyers, Wilson Tighe and Tim Rayner went onto BenchTV to discuss bail in NSW including the application of the Bail Act 2013 (NSW) and the process of a bail application in the local court, the district court and the Supreme Court.
Peter O’Brien comments on the William Tyrrell foster mother investigation – Jun 28, 2023
William Tyrrell’s foster mother has called on police to release the evidence they claim to have amassed against her after detectives asked prosecutors to charge her over the boy’s disappearance.
But, our Principal solicitor Peter O’Brien, the criminal defence lawyer who defended the first suspect identified in the case, washing machine repair man Bill Spedding, who has since been cleared warns that early police mistakes may now have ruined the investigation
He told the Sydney Morning Herald, “The longer a crime goes unsolved, the more difficulties police will have trying to solve it.”
Peter O’Brien comments on the Taser death of 95 year old Clare Nowland – May 27, 2023
As we recently reported, 95 year old woman Clare Nowland was the victim of a police tasering. Unfortunately she succumbed to the injuries she sustained in this episode. Police charged the responsible officer with assault, and it is now possible that the charges could upgrade to manslaughter.
Principal solicitor Peter O’Brien told the Sydney Morning Herald about the topic of police investigating police, “Since time immemorial it has been a thoroughly ineffective, unaccountable and unsound means of keeping the police accountable, for obvious reasons, and there are any number of examples to show that.”
Prosecutors lodge appeal after youth group leader Brett Edward Sorby granted bail – Mar 3, 2023
The church youth group leader, Brett Edward Sorby, who has remained in jail on remand since his arrest, was set for release after solicitor Peter O’Brien successfully applied for his conditional release on bail on Wednesday. A Newcastle Local Court magistrate granted it. However the Supreme Court will review the decision before Sorby goes free.
The 59-year-old faces 14 child sex charges concerning a teenage girl. These are historical offences, from between 2004 and 2005.
The article can be found here. This is behind a paywall
This brief version on the NBN Newcastle site is free to all.
Court dismisses bail for student following a protest at the Reserve Bank in Sydney
Our lawyers, Sidnie Sarang and Patrick Latham represent Cherish Kuehlmann
The legal right to protest is fundamental to the proper functioning of our democracy and is often not upheld.We successfully dismiss the heavy handed bail conditions imposed on her.
O’Brien Solicitors secures bail for former elite runner Eliza Stewart – Feb 2, 2023
Former elite runner Eliza Stewart got bail again after already breaching bail. Police charged her with selling more than $100,000 worth of stolen goods.
Stewart breached bail when police discovered the 36-year-old driving by herself. However her original bail conditions included that she was not to drive unaccompanied outside her home.
Our criminal defence lawyer, Wilson Tighe, persuaded Justice Richard Button to grant bail in the NSW Supreme Court on Thursday, February 2, 2023.
See how the West Australian media reported on this case.
If you are in need of a criminal defence lawyer, do not hesitate to contact us. We have the experience and expertise to defend your rights and ensure a fair trial.
Criminal Defence Lawyer Wilson Tighe
Sydney Channel 7 News covers the legal battle between Daniel Keneally & Clint Foster, featuring an interview with our principal solicitor Peter O’Brien – Jan 29, 2023
Son of former NSW Premier Kristina Keneally, Constable Daniel Keneally is in trouble again.
Our principal solicitor, Peter O’Brien, weighed in on the matter stating that police officers have a duty to “investigate it correctly, they’ve got to do it fairly, and they’ve got to do it impartially.”
If you are in need of a criminal defence lawyer, do not hesitate to contact us. We have the experience and expertise to defend your rights and ensure a fair trial.
Clint Foster – Former Premier Kristina Keneally’s Son Facing Police Investigation
2022
Stewart O’Connell, senior solicitor wins legal battle in court for Samantha Azzopardi – Dec 6, 2022
Samantha Azzopardi, who gained notoriety throughout the world with outrageous claims, got a significant win in the Downing Centre District Court in Sydney. Our lawyer, Stewart O’Connell, argued her 17-month jail sentence was “manifestly excessive” given Azzopardi’s complex mental health situation.
Stewart O’Connell even got international exposure in an Irish news outlet:
Some News Ltd outlets which reported on the case:
Bill Spedding maliciously prosecuted by NSW Police: Court Confirms – Dec 1, 2022
Click to read our Media Release.
Some News outlets that reported on the case:
- ABC News:
- 7 NEWS Australia: Former suspect in William Tyrrell case Bill Spedding wins $1.5 million after suing NSW Police
-
9 NEWS Australia: NSW Police ordered to pay $1.5 million to former suspect in William Tyrrell disappearance
- The Guardian: Bill Spedding: former suspect in William Tyrrell’s disappearance awarded $1.5m in damages
Senior solicitor Stewart O’Connell manages to secure bail for a man facing serious sexual predation charges – Nov 25, 2022
A young man got bail in the Supreme Court after he allegedly committed 19 “troubling predatory” offences against six underage girls. This included supplying two girls with alcohol before sexually assaulting them.
Stewart O’Connell, a senior criminal defence lawyer with O’Brien Solicitors, was able to convince the Judge that bail was appropriate, with strict conditions to prevent reoffending.
Peter Dutton defamation case against refugee activist Shane Bazzi ends with Opposition Leader deciding not to proceed further – Sep 26, 2022
Opposition Leader Peter Dutton’s defamation case against Shane Bazzi came to an end., with the Liberal leader dropping his high court appeal and the refugee activist ceasing a bid for costs.
Bazzi’s lawyers, O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors, revealed the pair reached a resolution with final orders emanating from the full Federal Court.
O’Brien Solicitors extract Victorian Police apology for client Dr Prasannan Ponganaparambile – Sep 21, 2022
Victoria Police published an apology to our client Dr Prasannan Ponganaparambile after they used social media to defame him by accusing him of being a suspect in a crime, followed by unlawfully imprisoning him. This apology was part of the confidential settlement that our defamation solicitor Stewart O’Connell got for the doctor.
Peter O’Brien interviewed for Australian Story for client Russell Manser – May 30, 2022
Australian Story published an episode on bank-robber turned survivor advocate Russell Manser. As Russell’s criminal lawyer, Peter O’Brien was interviewed by the ABC for the episode.
It aired on Monday 30 May 2022 however you can catch up on the episode here.
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors succeed in appeal against Peter Dutton for defamation against client Shane Bazzi – May 17, 2022
Shane Bazzi succeeded on appeal in the defamation case against Peter Dutton. Last year, the Minister for Defence sued Mr Bazzi over a tweet. At first instance, the Court ruled in Mr Dutton’s favour awarding him damages. However, on appeal, the Full Court held that the judge had erred in his reasoning. The Court further held that the tweet did not convey the pleaded imputation that “Mr Dutton excused rape”.
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors defamation team, consisting of Senior Solicitor Stewart O’Connell and Solicitor Sarah Gore, represented Mr Bazzi alongside Barristers Peter Gray SC and Barry Dean.
Appeal court overturns Peter Dutton’s $35,000 defamation win over tweet – Sydney Morning Herald
Shane Bazzi wins appeal in defamation case over Peter Dutton tweet – The Guardian
Refugee advocate Shane Bazzi wins court appeal against Peter Dutton – The Daily Telegraph
Updated:
Sep 27, 2022
Peter Dutton’s defamation case against refugee activist Shane Bazzi ends with resolution – The Guardian
media release – @obriensolicitor pic.twitter.com/gE2wXF5sBO
— Shane Bazzi (@shanebazzi) September 26, 2022
Stewart O’Connell, senior solicitor and defamation lawyer, featured in Terrance Flowers settlement – Feb 16, 2022
Seven West Media has settled a defamation lawsuit brought against it by O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors. It will pay out the man it wrongfully identified in news reports as Cleo Smith’s abductor.
Stewart O’Connell represented Terrance Flowers, who goes by his mother’s last name of Kelly on Facebook. He became the subject of mistaken identity when the Kerry Stokes-owned media conglomerate incorrectly identified him as Cleo’s abductor Terence Kelly.
News Articles which have quoted us:
Peter O’Brien, criminal defence lawyer, comments on Daryl James in Daily Telegraph article – Feb 7, 2022
Gold Coast man Daryl James, a promising young musician, suffered abuse as a teenage army apprentice. He then worked alongside his tormentors for 40 years. The Daily Telegraph reports that he has won his case against the Australian Defence Force (ADF) for the abuse.
Daily Telegraph reports on Daryl James abuse case settlement (may be behind a paywall for some users).
In the article, the Telegraph quotes Peter as follows:
Lawyer Peter O’Brien said the case sets a precedent for other ADF abuse victims.
“This claim was only for the conduct perpetrated against to Mr James – not for the subsequent mental and physical injuries that arose, nor any economic impact it had upon him. Therefore, it was not a personal injury claim,” he said.
“This is because Mr James’ has already been compensated for the impact the abuse had upon him but had not been compensated for the actions themselves.”
O’Brien Solicitors’ criminal defence lawyer Elliot Rowe acts on behalf of client Felix Dean – Jan 25, 2022
Actor Felix Dean had representation from our criminal defence lawyer Elliot Rowe at his sentencing hearing. Mr Dean found himself under arrest four times in the past 20 months. Subsequently, he pleaded guilty to a long list of charges involving violence and theft. The former Home and Away child star started using methamphetamine at the age of 15.
This high profile case saw coverage on Channel 9 as well as the following news articles.
Daily Mail reports on result on Felix Dean criminal case
News Corp sentencing article on Felix Dean violence offence cases
2021
O’Brien Solicitors to appeal on behalf of client Shane Bazzi in Peter Dutton defamation case – December 20, 2021
Refugee advocate files appeal over Peter Dutton’s $35,000 defamation win. Shane Bazzi, through his lawyers at O’Brien Solicitors, has filed an appeal against a Federal Court decision ordering him to pay Defence Minister Peter Dutton $35,000 in damages over a defamatory tweet.The following may be behind a paywall for some people:
Sydney Morning Herald reports on appeal on Bazzi defamation case
Neighbour mulls adding to William Tyrrell ‘suspects’ suing police – November 22, 2021
Peter O’Brien is quoted extensively in this article in The Australian where a neighbour of William Tyrrell considers suing police. Peter is already representing wrongly accused man Bill Spedding. The following may be behind a paywall:
The Australian quotes Peter O’Brien on Tyrrell case
Senior Solicitor Stewart O’Connell mentioned in Flowers defamation article – November 17, 2021
Terrance Flowers is suing Channel 7 for defamation over the Cleo Smith abduction. The following may be behind a paywall:
Terrance Flowers suing for defamation – Daily Telegraph
Man wrongly identified as suspect in Cleo Smith abduction is represented by O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors – November 5, 2021
Terrance Flowers goes by the name Terrance W. B. Kelly on Facebook, using his mother’s last name. This name is close to that of Carnarvon man Terence Darrell Kelly, who has been charged with child abduction. 4 year old Cleo Smith was found alive this week after having been missing for 18 days. Channel 7 incorrectly identified Mr Flowers as the suspect in the case including full face pictures. Consequently he suffered abuse and threats and ended up in hospital with a panic attack. He has engaged our firm to sue for defamation.
Peter O’Brien name-checked in Media Watch over Flowers defamation – November 5, 2021
Police officer in jail after assaulting woman, tampering with evidence – October 27, 2021
Peter O’Brien has a quote in a Canberra Times article about a police officer who assaulted a woman in a Liverpool pub. Subsequently, the officer lied about the interaction. The former senior constable, Mark Anthony Follington, is now in prison. O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors will be suing the NSW Police Force on the woman’s behalf.
Liverpool assault by police officer ends with him in prison – Canberra Times
Criminal defence case sees Barker College student escape conviction for Pyrmont assault – October 6, 2021
Peter O’Brien appeared for a Barker College student who faced a charge of assault occasioning actual bodily harm in company. Magistrate Sue Duncombe sentenced the 17 year old to 12-months probation in Children’s Court after he pleaded guilty to the crime. However, she recorded no conviction.
Pyrmont assault accused secures no conviction – News.com.au
Defamation case of Dylan Voller prevails in High Court of Australia – September 8, 2021
Dylan Voller is suing for defamation several media outlets including the Sydney Morning Herald and The Australian. Today the High Court of Australia agreed that those media outlets were responsible for libellous comments by commenters on the Facebook pages that the news outlets maintain.
Media outlets lose High Court appeal over Facebook defamation ruling – Sydney Morning Herald
High Court finds media outlets are responsible for Facebook comments in Dylan Voller defamation case – ABC
High court Voller ruling: Media liable defamation Facebook posts – Herald Sun
High Court decision will help clean up garbage on social media – Brisbane Times
Dylan Voller case: Nine, News Corp lose High Court appeal over Facebook comments defamation ruling – The Age
Australian media outlets liable for Facebook comments, court find – Reuters
You can see the statement that we released that the ABC quoted here.
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors’ takes on NSW Police over assault and false arrest of trans woman – May 28, 2021
Our civil lawyer team is suing NSW Police over an officer who was convicted of several counts relating to the unlawful assault and arrest of a woman in Liverpool.
Liverpool false arrest leads to conviction of police officer and lawsuit against NSW Police – Canberra Times
Sydney woman Anya Bradford sues NSW after being assaulted by police officer – ABC
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors’ Elliot Rowe defends stabbing accused – May 8, 2021
Criminal defence lawyer Elliot Rowe is defending a man who has pleaded not guilty to one count of reckless wounding on the Northern Beaches.
Collaroy alleged stabbing accused says it was self defence – The Daily Telegraph / Manly Daily (note this article is behind a pay wall)
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors represent Josh Massoud for defamation as he takes five media companies to court – April 27, 2021
Reports wrongly claimed Josh Massoud made ‘threat to kill’, court told
Senior Solicitor Stewart O’Connell, who specialises in defamation, is the solicitor acting for Ms Massoud.
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors to vigorously defend defamation suit from Peter Dutton – April 26-27, 2021
Defence Minister Peter Dutton is suing refugee activist Shane Bazzi over a tweet describing him as a “rape apologist”. O’Brien Solicitors civil team will be defending Mr Bazzi against the defamation claim.
Peter Dutton sues refugee advocate over ‘rape apologist’ tweet – Sydney Morning Herald
Peter Dutton sues refugee activist for defamation over tweet – The Guardian Australia
Peter Dutton sues Shane Bazzi over tweet – The Australian
O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors representing Doctor suing Victoria Police for defamation and unlawful arrest – April 16, 2021
A Melbourne doctor claims he was defamed by Victoria Police after he was accused on a local Facebook page of stealing a bottle of rum.
Prasannan Ponganamparambile is taking legal action against the State of Victoria over a social media post published on Victoria Police’s Cardinia Eyewatch Facebook page in May last year.
O’Brien Solicitors statement on the matter was quoted extensively in an article about the matter in The Age. Senior Solicitor Stewart O’Connell, who specialises in defamation, is one of the solicitors acting for the doctor.
“Mr O’Connell said his client was never charged and that Victoria Police’s actions had a devastating impact on Dr Ponganamparambile and his family.
He said police should not post a person’s image on social media connecting them to a crime “without at least a reasonable investigation into the circumstances”.
“People are entitled to the protection of the presumption of innocence and for their privacy to be respected,” he said.”
O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors has been engaged by someone in respect to Peter Dutton defamation action – April 7, 2021
Defence Minister Peter Dutton has launched an attack on critics on Twitter threatening to sue them for defamation.
O’Brien Solicitors statement on the matter was quoted extensively in an article about the threats in The Guardian.
“We have been engaged in relation to a defamation concerns notice served on an individual as a result of a tweet about Peter Dutton.
“We are not prepared, at this time, to discuss the specific details of the particular case.
“We are, however, firmly of the general view that politicians should not be wielding defamation laws as a sword to cut down the opinions and criticisms of individuals.
“People should have a broad freedom to criticise and express opinions about politicians without fear of reprisal, and politicians should have thick skins.”
O’Brien Solicitors argue defamation should be reserved for cases of “real risk of genuine damage to reputation”.
“That is not the case here. This was an expression of opinion on Twitter, a social media platform known for its freewheeling and informal banter in respect of matters of public interest, to an audience of no more than a few hundred people.”
Peter O’Brien quoted for an article on the ABC regarding payouts for child sexual assault in state custody – March 18, 2021
Peter O’Brien had a quote in an ABC article about sex assault compensation changes in NSW.
Solicitor Peter O’Brien said it was unfair to have one system for children in the community and another for those in custody.
“It was a horrendous piece of drafting to begin with to enable the state to avoid compensation payouts to those who’d been abused whilst in custody — in fact, in the care of the state as children,” he said.
2019-2020
Peter O’Brien interviewed for an article in The Guardian regarding police payouts for police misconduct – December 4, 2020
New South Wales police have paid out more than $100m in relation to legal settlements over the past four years. However, in most cases details of the suits were never made public. This is due to confidentiality clauses that prevent victims speaking about alleged officer misconduct.
The Guardian: ‘Hush’ money: NSW police pay out more than $100m in relation to legal settlements
Peter O’Brien featured in Daily Telegraph article on police payouts for unlawful arrest and false imprisonment – November 28, 2020
Peter travelled to a remote part of Indonesia with a backpack stuffed with cash. This was in order to convey money that two Indonesian youths were awarded after being falsely imprisoned by Australian Federal Police. The article also covers several other examples of police being sued for exceeding their powers such as unlawful arrest and false imprisonment.
Note that the following article may be behind a paywall. Here is our article on the topic.
Daily Telegraph: Australian police forced to pay millions for unlawful arrest and false imprisonment
Peter O’Brien quoted in Canberra Times article on NSW allowing protests with up to 500 people– October 23, 2020
Peter O’Brien has a quote on the topic of the NSW Government relaxing restrictions on demonstrations after several incidents of police brutality.
Canberra Times: NSW allows protests of up to 500 people in COVID-19 Public Health Order
Black Lives Matter advocates fight police in court for protest rights in Newcastle – July 3, 2020
Peter O’Brien is representing Taylah Gray from Fighting In Solidarity Towards Treaties (FISTT). He is fighting the latest attempt by the Police to deny a Black Lives Matter / Deaths in Custody protest the right to go ahead, this time in Newcastle.
SBS: An application will be heard in the NSW Supreme Court on Friday morning to prohibit a Black Lives Matter protest planned for Newcastle
Barristers for Deaths in Custody / Black Lives Matter protest rallies – June 13, 2020
The Wigs are not a truncated version of a children’s music group, but it is the name for a popular podcast featuring three of Sydney’s best barristers along with host Jim Minns. They and Peter O’Brien were key operatives in the recent Court of Appeals victory that won the Black Lives Matter / Deaths in Custody protest the right to go ahead.
Sydney Morning Herald: The barristers who make up the Wigs
Deaths in Custody / Black Lives Matter protest rallies behind the scenes – June 12, 2020
The Australian Financial Review has published a behind the scenes look at how Peter O’Brien and the other members of the legal team have been in the fight for the right to assemble in protest over the past week.
Australian Financial Review: Peter O’Brien and barristers and BLM / refugees protests
Deaths in Custody and Black Lives Matter protest demonstration rally backstory – June 9, 2020
Peter O’Brien and his criminal defence team were involved in the backstory to last weekend’s BLM rally. NSW Police gave the green light to the Sydney Black Lives Matter rally in an email sent two days before the event, the state’s top court has ruled, and their steps to reverse that authorisation failed.
Sydney Morning Herald: Court of Appeal rules Sydney Black Lives Matter protest can go ahead
Sydney Black Lives Matter rally organisers win last-minute appeal to overturn ban – June 6, 2020
Peter O’Brien acts for the BLM organizer Raul Bassi to win a go ahead for the major event.
Melbourne: arrest in Abbotsford leads to internal investigation by Victoria Police – June 7, 2020
7 News, Melbourne interviews Peter O’Brien as an expert on police brutality following a police officer using his foot to kick and then pin down a struggling man.
If the above Twitter link does not work, go to the 7 News Melbourne article directly.
Northern Territory Don Dale detainees tear gas High Court decision – June 4, 2020
Peter O’Brien acted for Don Dale detainees, is quoted in this article by Barrister and law lecturer, Greg Barns, about the High Court decision about the use of tear gas on them.
Sydney Morning Herald: Don Dale ruling a strong message against use of force on children
Cognitive Impairment Diversion Program (CIDP) under threat – June 2, 2020
Peter O’Brien’s letter to the Attorney General on the Cognitive Impairment Diversion Program (CIDP) is having an impact. He is quoted in this article from the Sydney Morning Herald today.
Sydney Morning Herald: CIDP under menace
Cognitive Impairment Diversion Program (CIDP) radio interview – June 2, 2020
Peter O’Brien spoke to James Valentine on ABC Radio Sydney on Tuesday about the Cognitive Impairment Diversion Program (CIDP) and how it is imperilled by possible lack of funding. This would mean that some of the most vulnerable in society would face dire consequences due to the uncompromising rigidity of the criminal justice system. To listen to the interview, go to this page.
ABC Radio: James Valentine Cognitive Impairment Diversion Program (CIDP) interview
Peter O’Brien present at William Tyrell’s coronial inquest – June 1, 2020
Peter O’Brien is representing local white-goods repairman, Bill Spedding, who is suing NSW police for naming him as a suspect when no evidence connects him to the crime.
The Australian: William Tyrell coronial inquest (Paywall site, so you may need to be a subscriber)
Garbage truck driver cleared over Sydney grandmother’s death – May 7, 2020
Peter O’Brien successfully defended a garbage truck driver who reversed into a legally blind woman on the Northern Beaches. The charge was dangerous driving. See also our media release on the case.
Nine News: Dangerous driving charge not guilty
Social distancing COVID-19 fines application criticised by Peter O’Brien – April 23, 2020
The Nine News website include this article sourced from the Australian Associated Press (AAP):
Nine News: NSW COVID-19 fines ‘arbitrarily applied’
As COVID-19 social distancing regulations bite, Peter O’Brien is quoted in the Guardian – April 14, 2020
In an article about someone’s funeral being broken up by police (!), among other possible over-reaches, Peter O’Brien is quoted:
The Guardian: social distancing enforcement by police
Cardinal George Pell opinion piece in the Guardian by Peter O’Brien – April 14, 2020
Peter O’Brien, Principal Solicitor of O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors, was approached by The Guardian to provide an opinion piece regarding the recent High Court decision in the matter of ex-cardinal George Pell. Read it here:
The Guardian: Cardinal George Pell appeal consequences
Social distancing Coronavirus fines application unfair impact criticised by Peter O’Brien – April 27, 2020
The News website include this article sourced from the Australian Associated Press (AAP):
News: NSW Coronavirus fines impacting vulnerable groups
60 Minutes Ben Batterham segment – March 15, 2020
Benjamin Batterham was at his home, in Hamilton, an inner city suburb of Newcastle, having drinks with a friend in the early hours of 26 March 2016 when he saw a man in his house, coming out of his baby daughter’s room. The man was holding what would later be found to be his wife’s baby bag. In the chase the then took place, the home invader would end up losing his life. Find out what happened next in a case led by principal solicitor, Peter O’Brien, in the following 60 Minutes video.
Defamation claim of the Yolngu people in the Northern Territory versus Channel 7 and the Sunrise program – December 16, 2019
Our principal lawyer Peter O’Brien, and solicitor Stewart O’Connell, were in the news last week. This publicity related to the defamation claim of the Yolgnu people in the Northern Territory versus Channel 7 and content broadcast on their Sunrise program. You can discover more about the media coverage in the following links:
Guardian: Channel Seven settles defamation case with Aboriginal community over Sunrise segment
Sydney Morning Herald: Seven settles with Aboriginal group over ‘Stolen Generation’ Sunrise panel
B And T: Seven’s Sunrise To Issue Public Apology & Payout Over Stolen Generation Segment
4 Corners Bill Spedding episode – Nov 4, 2019
On Monday, ABC Four Corners will reveal how a man was wrongly accused in the William Tyrrell investigation. Bill Spedding, a washing machine repairman, was accused of abducting the three-year-old William Tyrrell, who disappeared in 2014 from the front yard of a family home in Kendall, on NSW’s mid-north coast. Police pursued Spedding, and principal solicitor, Peter O’Brien was able to prove his innocence, as is demonstrated in this Four Corners episode:
South Australia to outlaw use of spit hoods in youth detention centres – 25/09/2019
The South Australian Ombudsman has found South Australia is the only state or territory that still uses spit hoods in youth detention centres. Peter O’Brien features in the ABC PM audio podcast.
ABC PM – South Australia to outlaw use of spit hoods in youth detention centres
Inquest into William Tyrrell’s disappearance adjourned until 2020 despite gripping statement – 31/08/2019
After five weeks of evidence, dozens of witnesses and two separate courthouses, the inquest into the disappearance of NSW toddler William Tyrrell has come to a standstill.
News.com.au – Inquest into William Tyrrell’s disappearance adjourned until 2020 despite gripping statement
William Tyrrell inquest to grill axed detective over his ‘methods’ – 28/06/2019
Former homicide detective Gary Jubelin will be called as a witness at the inquest into the disappearance of three-year-old William Tyrrell. Counsel for various “persons of interest” are keen to cross-examine him about his methods.
The Australian – William Tyrrell inquest to grill axed detective over his ‘methods’
Dylan Voller wins landmark social media defamation case – 24/06/2019
Former Northern Territory youth detainee Dylan Voller won against three media organisations for defamation over a series of claims made about him in the comments section of Facebook posts. Read our media release here.
Sydney Morning Herald – Media companies liable for Facebook comments made by others, court finds
SBS – Court rules in favour of Voller defamation case brought against media outlets
ABC – AM Radio – Traditional media reacts angrily to landmark defamation ruling
Channel Seven fails to stop Aboriginal group’s Sunrise defamation lawsuit – 13/06/2019
Residents from a remote Aboriginal community launched a defamation lawsuit against Seven West Media over a controversial breakfast show segment. Channel Seven tried and failed to strike out the lawsuit at a Federal Court hearing in Sydney. Our law firm is representing 15 plaintiffs, including 6 children, from Yirrkala community. Read our media release here.
SBS – Channel Seven fails to stop Aboriginal group’s Sunrise defamation lawsuit
Yirrkala people sue Channel Seven over Sunrise segment – 05/04/2019
Residents of Yirrkala Aboriginal community have sued Channel Seven for defamation after a controversial Sunrise segment. The program illustrated a story about abuse on Aboriginal children while showing alleged footage of Yirrkala residents. Despite a blurring filter used by the program, adults and children were still able to be seen and identified. Our law firm is representing the residents of the Yirrkala community. Read our media release here.
ABC News – Yirrkala residents launch defamation action against Channel Seven’s Sunrise
News.com.au – Residents of small Indigenous community launch defamation action against Sunrise
The Australian – Blurred footage on Sunrise ‘made Aborigines targets of ridicule’
B&T – Channel Seven sued over controversial and ‘disturbing’ segment of Sunrise
Dorendahl Inquest – 26/04/2019
Mother Michelle Dorendahl was pregnant with her second child when her young daughter Eeva lost her life in tragic circumstances that were considered by a coronial inquest. Principal lawyer Peter O’Brien represented Ms Dorendahl at the inquest and always suspected the daughter’s late father Mr Hutchings caused the deaths. Read the full coverage of the Dorendahl inquest below.
Weekend Australian – Mother’s futile search for answers over Eeva’s death in a system fatally flawed
Children not returned by parents in custody disputes to be treated as missing, coroner says – 27/03/2019
A coronial inquest into the deaths of Greg Hutchings, and his 4-year-old daughter, Eeva Dorendahl, has recommended police treat children as missing persons if they are not returned by parents involved in custody disputes. Peter O’Brien represented Eeva’s mother, Ms Michelle Dorendahl, at the inquest and said Mr Hutchings had always been suspected of causing the deaths.
ABC News – Children not returned by parents in custody disputes to be treated as missing, coroner says
Former Seven reporter Josh Massoud launches defamation action – 07/03/2019
Sports journalist Josh Massoud has taken legal action against more than half a dozen media outlets over the coverage of his departure from the Seven Network. Stewart O’Connell is representing Massoud, who said there was a significant difference between what the parties involved agreed occurred and what certain sections of the media actually reported.
Sydney Morning Herald – Former Seven reporter Josh Massoud launches defamation action
Fee structure works as an incentive to delay a case – 13/02/2019
Private lawyers who are funded by Legal Aid NSW were unfairly criticised last week after research from the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (BOCSAR) was released. Peter O’Brien said a lot of private lawyers do very high-quality work for legal aid clients at what is a fraction of commercial rates.
Sydney Morning Herald- Fee structure works as an incentive to delay a case
2016-2018
Police pursue ‘active’ leads’ into William Tyrrell’s disappearance – 21/12/2018
William Tyrrell disappeared more than 4 years ago without a trace, but the Coroner’s Court heard there is a chance he’s still alive.
The Sydney Morning Herald – NSW Police searching ‘active leads’ into William Tyrrell’s disappearance
‘Cult leader’ ordered to pay blogger’s legal costs – 07/12/2018
The Sydney Morning Herald – Cult Leader uses defamation case to inflict pain on blogger
Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse in the Newcastle Anglican diocese- 23/11/2016
Peter O’Brien questions former Newcastle dean Graeme Lawrence during the Royal Commission.
O’Brien puts it to Lawrence that others have said he was a paedophile.
“I totally reject that,” Lawrence says.
He denies being questioned in 1997 about allegations against him and has denied the evidence of others that he was the person at the end of a child sexual abuse hotline run by the Anglican Diocese of Newcastle.
“I was not handling a hotline,” Lawrence said.
O’Brien: “You were the fox in charge of the hen house.”
“No.”
“You were protecting priests from allegations of child sexual abuse.”
“I did not.”
Asked whether he had “any inclination” to either a priest or a complainant” in any matter, Lawrence said: “I don’t recall any approaches.”
Read the full blog from Day 15 of the Royal Commission in the Newcastle Herald here:
Principal Solicitor Peter O’Brien interviewed on Channel 7 news- 07/11/2018
Peter O’Brien speaking at an SBS Forum on Juvenile Justice.
Solicitor Stewart O’ Connell featuring in the Serge Benhayon Defamation case- 23/10/2018
Self-styled healer Serge Benhayon leads ‘socially harmful cult’: jury – October 15, 2018
Aboriginal boy sues Alice Springs newspaper for defamation – Sep 28, 2018
ABC Media Watch – NT newspaper settles after using Indigenous child as the face of youth crime
The Guardian – Centralian Advocate settles out of court over front-age photo of Aboriginal boy
@IndigenousX – NT Defamation Case in Supreme Court
Bail granted for client – May 3, 2018
SMH – Man accused of killing intruder granted bail for second time
Dylan Voller & Jake Roper’s Civil claim against NT government
SBS News – Don Dale inmates paid $100k for abuse
