Magistrate resigns over drug driving laws
Lismore Magistrate David Heilpern stood down from his position earlier this year citing unethical drug driving laws. Mr Heilpern stated that the laws were so “grossly unfair” that he could no longer apply them.
“[T]he vast majority of people who are brought before the courts on this charge, are not affected [by the drug],” he told ABC RN’s Law Report.
Mr Heilpern told the ABC that evidence of decreased road tolls were clear on the introduction of both roadside breath testing and the introduction of seatbelts. However, roadside drug testing has not had the same effect.
The RBT program works because there is a proven and clear link between blood alcohol content, alcohol intake and intoxication. The link between intoxication and the presence of THC is not scientifically proven.
“I have seen nothing to show that there is any reduction in the road toll as a result of the thousands and thousands of people who are appearing before courts for historic use of cannabis,” Mr Heilburn said.
Professor McGregor from the University of Sydney stated that “we should instead be focusing on developing novel methods for detecting drivers who are actually impaired by cannabis. The two devices used by police in Mobile Drug Testing (MDT) were never designed to measure impairment.”
This year, NSW Police aim to conduct 200,000 mobile drug tests – a considerable increase from previous years. With the area in need of reform, this large number of testing opens a wide net of disaster.
How much does THC affect driving?
THC is the main psychoactive compound in marijuana. It’s the component of the drug that gives the “high” effect.
Even if someone returns a true positive for THC in the system, the question remains as to the effect of cognitive ability to drive. We know from drink driving that the law allows for a certain limit of alcohol in the system, to where intoxication affects driving negatively. However, drug tests, including for marijuana, only return a Yes/No response.
Professor McGregor told the ABC that intoxication from alcohol was different from that of cannabis.
“I’m certainly not an advocate for driving under the influence of cannabis but it’s a mistake to consider that cannabis driving is equivalent to alcohol driving,” Professor McGregor said.
HOW LONG AFTER SMOKING MARIJUANA CAN I DRIVE?
In 2015 a man waited nine days after smoking marijuana before he got behind the wheel and still tested positive to the drug. Earlier, he had been told by police to wait at least a week before driving. He was found not guilty by Magistrate Heilpern – a very rare win for this man. (link)
In 2018 a man tested positive for a roadside drug test after relying on information from the NSW Centre for Road Safety website which indicated “cannabis can typically be detected in saliva by an MDT test stick for up to 12 hours after use.” The website now states “Illegal drugs can be detected in your saliva by an MDT for a significant time after drug use, even if you feel you are OK to drive.”
THE IMPACT OF A CONVICTION
“People would lose their licence, therefore they would lose their job. Therefore, they could well lose their house. Their relationships were affected. People became very much more isolated,” Mr Heilpern told the ABC.
A study from the University of Sydney found that the roadside test for THC in saliva, which is used to detect cannabis, often produced positive readings for extremely low levels of THC – 5 per cent of the time. The device also frequently failed to detect high amounts of cannabis – 16 per cent of the time.
After the roadside test turns a positive result, drivers are taken into an MDT van and a second saliva sample is reviewed by the Draeger DrugTest 5000. Researchers found that this test gave a false positive reading 10 per cent of the time and a false negative 9 per cent of the time.
Given the aim to conduct 200,000 tests, the unreliability of the test means that up to 10,000 people in NSW could be banned from driving for 24 hours until lab results come back confirming it was a negative reading. It also means that up to 32,000 people who are heavily under the influence of marijuana could return a false negative.
If you have been the subject of a Roadside Drug Test or police misconduct, O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors are able to pursue your possible claim anywhere in Australia. Please don’t hesitate to contact us today on 02 9261 4281 or by email at