Historical Abuse Case at Youth Detention Centre: John*, a client of O’Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors, obtained a significant outcome in a civil case brought against the State of New South Wales. The case centred on serious allegations of historical mistreatment during John’s time at a juvenile detention. Litigation in the Supreme Court of NSW resulted in a resolution that delivered long-awaited justice.
Case Summary: Historical Abuse Case at Youth Detention Centre
John was a vulnerable young person when he was placed in the care of two NSW juvenile detention centres. While detained, he suffered serious mistreatment and sexual abuse at the hands of state-employed officers. This included repeated physical mistreatment, highly invasive conduct, among other atrocious acts. The events spanned several years and had a devastating long-term impact on John’s life.
The civil claim, lodged in the Supreme Court of NSW, alleged multiple failures by the State to protect John during his detention. These included a failure to:
- supervise staff adequately,
- to ensure proper vetting and training,
- and to implement systems that would prevent such abuse.
The case was strongly defended by the State. With legal representation from our civil lawyers, the matter was fully litigated. Ultimately, John secured a substantial settlement in recognition of the harm he suffered.
Detailed Overview of Abuse Case at Youth Detention Centre
John’s legal action claimed that, while he was detained as a teenager:
-
He experienced repeated mistreatment by officers in positions of authority including sexual abuse.
-
He was heavily encouraged and instructed to commit other harmful acts.
-
He was placed in vulnerable situations that exposed him to further harm.
The Statement of Claim alleged that the State of NSW had breached its duty of care by failing to protect John from serious harm while he was under their custody. The officers responsible were acting in their roles as employees or agents of the State, which made the State vicariously liable.
Failures by the state
Key failures identified in the claim included:
-
Inadequate supervision of staff.
-
Failure to screen or train officers appropriately.
-
A lack of safeguards to prevent mistreatment and substance access.
-
Breaches of both domestic laws and international conventions protecting children in detention.
Our legal team argued successfully that these failings caused John long-term psychological harm. Considerable damages were warranted given the extreme abuse of power involved. Importantly, the Civil Liability Act was not applied to this case due to the criminal and abusive nature of the conduct, allowing for broader heads of damage to be claimed.
Outcome of Abuse Case at Youth Detention Centre
The Supreme Court matter concluded with a significant settlement for John. This outcome followed a hard-fought legal process and represented meaningful recognition of the severe harm he had endured. The financial compensation will support John’s ongoing recovery and future needs.
Although the terms remain confidential due to the nature of the case, the resolution was a clear success for John and a testament to the power of civil proceedings to hold institutions accountable.
Need a lawyer for an Abuse Case at Youth Detention Centre?
If you, or someone you know, has experienced harm while in institutional care, civil legal remedies may be available. Our team has deep expertise in complex and sensitive historical abuse cases. We act with discretion, respect, and unwavering commitment to achieving justice.
Enquire online or call O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors on (02) 9261 4281 or email . We can also set up a free appointment with the civil lawyers in our Sydney office.
*Name changed to protect the client’s identity.
