Proactive policing has been a topic of significant debate, particularly concerning the use of stop and search powers in NSW. While these measures are intended to enhance public safety and prevent crime, there have been numerous reports highlighting the abuse of these powers.
We delve into the issues surrounding stop and search practices. In particular, we’ll look at specific cases of false arrest. Plus, we’ll discuss the recent news about the rise in searches and police misconduct.
Read: NSW Police Proactive Policing – What Happened To Brad Balzan?
Understanding Stop and Search Powers in NSW
The Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (LEPRA) governs the stop and search powers of NSW police officers.
Under LEPRA, police can stop and search individuals or vehicles without a warrant if they have “reasonable suspicion” that the person is in possession of:
- stolen goods,
- illegal drugs,
- weapons,
- or other items related to criminal activity.
However, the definition of “reasonable suspicion” is not always clear, leading to potential misuse.
Rise in stop and searches and Controversies
Increase in stop and search powers in NSW
One of the most controversial aspects of proactive policing in NSW has been the dramatic rise in strip searches.
Between 2006 and 2018, the use of strip searches increased twentyfold. A significant number of these searches resulted in no illegal items. In 2017-18 alone, over 5,000 individuals were strip-searched. With 64% of these searches finding nothing. This has led to widespread criticism and calls for reform.
Quotas and Targets: stop and search powers in NSW
During the 2020-21 financial year, NSW police were given quotas to conduct more personal searches. This strategy led to a 1.8% increase in overall search targets compared to the previous year. This quota-driven approach has been criticised for incentivising unnecessary and invasive searches.
Cases of Abuse and False Arrest
Ebonie Madden Case
One notable case highlighting the misuse of stop and search powers is that of Ebonie Madden.
In 2020, Madden was jailed for six months after a search in Penrith led to charges of resisting arrest, possessing a knife, and theft. However, a judge later ruled the search unlawful. The judge found that the police did not have reasonable grounds to justify it. In the end, Madden was awarded $320,000 in compensation for malicious prosecution and false imprisonment.
Danny Lim Incident
In another case, Danny Lim was charged with offensive conduct for wearing a sandwich board with a political statement. Although he was initially found guilty, the conviction was overturned on appeal. There was a national outcry over his violent arrest. This case highlighted issues with the police’s interpretation and application of their powers.
Misconduct in Stop and Search powers in NSW
The Law Enforcement Conduct Commission (LECC) has conducted multiple inquiries into the misuse of strip search powers by NSW police. These investigations revealed systemic abuses, including illegal strip searches of minors and Indigenous individuals. In one instance, a 15-year-old Aboriginal boy was humiliated by officers while restrained and sedated. This case resulted to a finding of serious misconduct against the involved officers.
Proactive Policing and Community Impact
The proactive policing strategies in NSW, including the use of stop and search powers, have had a significant impact on community relations. The overuse and misuse of these powers have led to a loss of trust in law enforcement. This feeling is particularly strong among marginalised communities. For example, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander individuals, have been disproportionately targeted. In turn, this fact has risen concerns about discrimination and systemic bias.
Government and Police Responses
In response to the growing criticism, the NSW Police Force has taken steps to address some of these issues. For instance, the controversial Suspect Target Management Plan (STMP) for minors was recently abandoned following a damning report from the LECC. Additionally, the police have scrapped the quota system for searches. Both of these steps acknowledge the need for a more balanced approach.
Additionally, the NSW government has also implemented various measures to improve police accountability and community relations. These include the introduction of body-worn cameras to record interactions. Plus, the establishment of independent oversight bodies like the LECC to investigate complaints against police officers.
Stop and search powers in NSW – misused or needed?
While proactive policing aims to enhance public safety, the misuse and abuse of stop and search powers in NSW have raised significant concerns. The rise in invasive searches, cases of false arrest, and reports of police misconduct highlights the need for comprehensive reforms.
Ensuring that police actions are based on reasonable suspicion and are conducted lawfully is crucial for maintaining public trust and protecting individual rights. As NSW continues to address these challenges, it is essential to balance proactive policing with accountability and respect for civil liberties.
